Writing is self-evidently an uncinematic endeavour and consequently films have tended to steer clear of attempting to depict it. It's not so much that films are anti-intellectual: there have been numerous biopics of painters, composers, musicians and even dancers. I think it's more to do with the fact that writing is perceived to be a solitary, silent and private pursuit that produces an end result which is consumed in a similar fashion. However, poetry - for the most part - is intended to be heard and this is particularly true of Allen Ginsberg's work.
HOWL works because as well as exploring who Ginsberg was and how that led to the writing of the poem, it contains a performance of the poem itself. And not only does the film show Franco as Ginsberg reciting the poem at the Six Gallery in 1955 but it also uses music and animation to visualise the text. In effect, the film-makers have recognised that the act of writing - the literal act of putting pen to paper, finger to typewriter - is, unlike painting or dancing, merely a mechanical process and that what is of real interest is what is being written and how it came to be written.
The court-room stuff, which dramatises the 1957 obscenity trial of Laurence Ferlinghetti for publishing 'Howl and other poems', is less essential in my view but I suppose what it does is provide a social and cultural context to the poem. I think the problem with those sections is that they settle for a rather obvious Us and Them / Squares vs Hipsters / Good vs Evil opposition; clipped, straight-laced David Strathairn is the prosecutor and beefy, heroic Jon Hamm (from TV's MAD MEN) is the defence attorney. The witnesses who think Howl has cultural merit are groovy liberals and those who think it obscene are straight-laced reactionaries. I'm sorry to say I don't know enough about the US in the late '50s, or the trial itself, to know for sure but I'd like to think it wasn't as binary as that. Nevertheless, I can only assume that the dialogue from these sequences is taken from transcripts of the trial and therefore it is possible to say that cultural and social freedoms were being fought for by some very brave people.
Jon Hamm (L) and David Strathairn (R) await the judge's ruling |
James Franco as Allen Ginsberg |